Skip to content
Living Courageously in Overwhelming Times

Do You Know Your Hinduism? Notes for Modern-Day Hindus

A comprehensive review of Rajmohan Gandhi's latest book

Do You Know Your Hinduism? Notes for Modern-Day Hindus
Do You Know Your Hinduism? Notes for Modern-Day Hindus by Rajmohan Gandhi (New Delhi: Aleph, 2026)

What is the alternative to the religious nationalism prevalent in the world today, which often fuels war and social conflict? In this short, programmatic book, Indian public intellectual Rajmohan Gandhi explores this question in a Hindu and Indian context.

The book’s central message is that the world’s 1.2 billion Hindus face a defining choice. On the one hand, they could embrace the Hindu nationalism which has become so strong in today’s India—and is associated with Prime Minister Narendra Modi—or, on the other, they could opt for a more benevolent, values-based spirituality that would enhance Indian democracy and be a positive contribution to social cohesion in countries outside India where Hindus are present in increasing numbers. They will not be somehow lesser Hindus or—if they are Indian citizens—less Indian, if they choose the second option.

Gandhi is a grandson of M. K. Gandhi (the ‘Mahatma’), and a leading interpreter of his life and legacy. His biography Gandhi: The Man, His People and the Empire (2006) is regarded as one of the best one-volume studies of the Indian anti-colonial leader, while works of his such as Why Gandhi Still Matters (2017) and James Lawson: Teacher of Satyagraha(2026) explore the history and relevance of the doctrine of non-violence. He has written widely on South Asian history, often focussing on ethical and spiritual issues.

This book includes a chapter on M. K. Gandhi’s spirituality. The Mahatma was a serious Hindu, we learn: ‘I am a Hindu with every fibre of my being,’ he once said. But he was also a nation-builder in an ethnically and religiously diverse country, and this led him to try to bring together unconnected and often alienated elements in society. In this context, he was always eager to heal the social wounds caused by Hindu-Muslim and other religious violence.

The Mahatma’s respect for other faiths and traditions of thought is strongly emphasised here: he drew inspiration from outside Hinduism as well as from within it. For example, he found a ‘message of love’ in the teachings of Zoroaster, the Buddha, Moses, Jesus and Muhammad, and admired Tolstoy and Thoreau. He was also a reformer who criticised retrograde practices. In 1927, when Brahmin priests came to him citing scripture in defence of untouchability and child marriage, he declared that Hinduism was not upheld by quoting isolated texts but by acting through the ‘inner voice of conscience’.

Gandhi rejects the idea that his grandfather could have done more to oppose Partition. He argues that it would not have worked for him to ‘fast against’ Lord Mountbatten’s 1947 Partition Plan—which he disliked—because the Indian National Congress, led by Jawaharlal Nehru and Vallabhbhai Patel, had by then come round to endorsing the division of the country into India and Pakistan, and wider Indian opinion was not so opposed to Partition as to justify a campaign against it.

Gandhi explains that he devotes a chapter to his grandfather not because he is preeminent among Hindu thinkers, but because he has studied him more than others. He thus presents him as a representative of an already existing spiritual tradition rather than the founder of a new one. Hinduism is certainly shown here to be rich in resources for strengthening social bonds and interfaith understanding. For example, in the opening chapter Gandhi points to the presence in Hindu thought of the idea that humanity, taken as a whole, has a familial character. He finds evidence for this in the Sanskrit phrase ‘Vasudhaiva Kutumbakam’, originating in the Maha Upanishad, meaning ‘the whole world is one family’, and a Tamil expression that translates as ‘Wherever born, he or she is my relative’.

Gandhi then cites a series of thinkers who, he believes, represent Hinduism at its best. This includes reformers like the Raja Ram Rohan Roy (1772–1833), founder in 1828 of the Brahmo Sabha, which opposed sati, polygamy and child marriage, and the Gujarati founder of the Arya Saraj, Dayanand Saraswati (1824–1883), who rejected superstition and caste distinctions while upholding reason, truth and the status of women. He also includes here the Nobel Prize-winning poet and author of the Indian national anthem, Rabindranath Tagore (1861–1941), who saw a place for all of India’s religions in the country’s life.

According to Gandhi, there is a Hindu approach to social relationships which involves treating all human beings with ‘acceptance, respect, and goodwill’. He clearly hopes Hindus might find a sense of global purpose in representing this ethos; indeed, his book could be seen as an attempt to equip them for this task. If enough of them were to adopt this approach, he says, it might come to be known as ‘the Hindu approach’. 

Gandhi’s vision for Hindus is spiritual as well as moral. The book includes the text of a popular hymn by Punjabi author Shardha Ram (1837–1881), ‘Om Jai Jagadish Hare’. This speaks of God as the ‘Knower of my Inmost Being’ and the ‘friend of the helpless’, phrases that will remind Jews and Christians of the Psalms. Ram’s God is both outside and inside people, Gandhi remarks, arguing that the hymn could be a plea by ‘anyone to everyone’s God’.

In a sense, by pooling these ideas and thinkers, Gandhi is fashioning his own Hindu tradition, one he sees as fit for purpose in a complex, rapidly changing world. He implicitly acknowledges this by observing that his selection of Hindu thinkers is ‘personal’. Nevertheless, he says it aligns with ‘history’s graph’. He also suggests that it reflects a thought expressed in the Rig Veda (an ancient collection of Sanskrit hymns): ‘Truth is one. The wise speak of it in many ways.’ In this way, he argues that his selection is not arbitrary but morally coherent and authentically Hindu.

Gandhi is fighting a battle over what history teaches us. He challenges narratives emphasising how India has historically been humiliated by foreign powers. In his view, what he calls the ‘revenge drive’ in modern India is energised by distorted or mythical accounts of the past. On this subject, he criticises the nationalist Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS) organisation headed by Mohan Bhagwat, which stresses the connection between Hindu identity and a person’s bloodline or place of birth. ‘Hindu victimhood’ was a key plank in the RSS’s ideology from its inception in the 1920s, he suggests.

Gandhi does not ignore the violence inflicted on India by Muslim invaders, while he also mentions the British treatment of Indians as second-class citizens. But he argues that India, through centuries of subjugation, proved able to ‘tame, absorb, and Indianize’ the nation’s occupiers. He also floats the idea that while Hindu chiefs were defeated militarily by Muslims in certain crucial battles, Hindus were triumphant in the arguably more important wars of ‘ideas, trade and influence’. The Indian native population comes across here as durable and resilient. ‘We have had a proud history. Why then do we want revenge?’ Gandhi asks.

But he also argues that the legacy of invaders was not always negative, with non-Hindu rulers playing an important role in constructing India’s political system. The British built the modern Indian state on the foundations of the Hindostan organised earlier by the Mughals, he says. He stresses that when Islamic rule first came to northern India in the late twelfth century—in the form of Muhammad Ghori’s Sultanate—it was not imposed on a unified Indian kingdom, because such a state did not exist. In this context, he calls an Indian state the ‘Great Absence’.

There is an alternative to the communal violence from which India has sometimes suffered, Gandhi wants to say.  At the end of the book, he cites an episode in 2023 when a team of Hindu and Muslim labourers worked to free forty-one men trapped in a tunnel in the northern state of Uttarakhand. This gives a vivid picture of the kind of collaborative humanitarianism he wants Hindus to support, and which he believes Hinduism, as a religious and intellectual tradition, can help sustain. More broadly, Gandhi’s text implicitly invites people of all faiths to distinguish what is nationalistic in their ideas and attitudes from what speaks to all of humanity. It will interest anyone grappling with the relationship between religion and nation in polarised societies.

*This article is being reproduced with permission. See the original article in Munitions of the Mind, a blog run by the Centre for the History of War, Media and Society at the University of Kent.

Philip Boobbyer

Philip Boobbyer

Dr. Philip Boobbyer is Reader Emeritus in History at the University of Kent where he taught European, Russian and Cold War history. His works include "Conscience, Dissent and Reform in Soviet Russia" (2005) and "Geography, Money and War" (2021).

All articles
Tags: Book Reviews

More in Book Reviews

See all

More from Philip Boobbyer

See all